Why Twitter Should Never Expand Beyond 140 Characters

Last week, I came across an interesting article on ReadWriteWeb titled: Why Twitter Must Expand Beyond 140 Characters. Going by the title alone, I can say without hesitation that calling it a bad idea would be an understatement. In fact, I believe it would completely kill the very essence of Twitter.

To give RWW the benefit of the doubt (and to prepare for this piece) I of course read it and expectedly, there were some interesting points but alas, nothing particularly convincing. The post was inspired by the new Tweetdeck feature, deck.ly, that allows users to tweet more than 140-characters. RWW founder and Editor in Chief Richard McManus believes that longer messages will eventually be a requirement for Twitter to expand to the mainstream.

First of all, the Deck.ly idea isnt particularly new. Services like twitlonger have been around for a while and people have been using it in the most used client of all time the Twitter.com web app. Throughout this piece, I will be presenting counter-arguments to the points raised by McManus.

Twitter Is No Longer About Constraints

Saying something is a constraint sounds so derogatory. For semantics sake, I would rather call it a creative feature and thats exactly what Twitter is all about that. Its a completely different user experience that caters to a particular crowd.

Theres actually a reason behind the not-so-arbitrary 140 character limit of Twitter and that is simply to fit in an SMS message. Its a limitation that actually defines and sets Twitter apart from other services in so many good ways. It is easier to consume, cheaper in terms! of SMS/ data sent and received, and it actually encourages people to get straight to the point.

A lot can be said in 140 words. If you need to say more, theres actually something that works better than deck.ly. Its called WordPress.

That Extra Click: The User Experience Issue

However there is a significant user experience issue with that, in that it often introduces an extra click for the user. A lot of Twitters beauty as a consumer of tweets is that you can scan a bunch of tweets in one go.

I actually agree the extra click is a chore. But thats exactly why its a feature and not a constraint. If you really have something worthwhile to share, make sure its something that will make people click based on the first 140 characters.

One things for sure, Id rather click on a few useful, important links than having to scroll through everyone elses longer tweets. Not only will it end up taking longer, it will simply massacre the simplicity and ease of experience that is Twitter.

Will Twitter Producers Pollute Twitter With Long Tweets?

Twitter users wont stop producing short tweets just because long ones become available to them. Theyll use the long tweets sparingly, because theyve been habituated into doing short tweets.

This is where it becomes complicated. McManus claims that Twitter must remove the limit but they must also monitor use to prevent a drastic change in user behavior. I cant help but feel that the McManus isnt completely convinced himself.

While people who are accustomed to Twitter might stick to short tweets, there will also be a huge number of new subscribers to the service. Back in 2010, Twitter had almost 200 million accounts but 80% of the users tweeted fewer than ten times. Moreover, 40% of them never even sent a single tweet at all. Its also important ! to menti on that it was growing at around 6.4 million new users per month. This is phenomenal, and it would be foolish to not take these new users into consideration.

Without a character limitation, Twitter will actually beeasier to promote to mainstream users. It will remove an extra barrier for people to start using Twitter.

Actually I feel quite the contrary. If tweets were even just as long as the first paragraph of the excerpt of this blog, it would definitely be long, tedious, and a complete turn-off especially for mobile users, whoaccount for 40% of all Twitter users.

Other Languages Already Send Long Messages on Twitter

Twitter users in China can easily express in-depth thoughts because the Chinese language allows Twitter users to express 140 words on Twitter and not just 140 characters.

Characters and words do not exactly equate to a message. It all depends on how one structures a sentence or a phrase. Again this goes back to the reason why it is limited to 140 characters, which is not because the creators of Twitter didnt want us to convey messages. Rather, to be creative and smart by communicating a message using the fewest possible words.

Cant think of a shorter way to write Tweets? Try Thsrs, a service that actually lets you find shorter synonyms of words, or any of the other suggestions in ourarticle: How to squeeze more into your tweets.

Twitter Should Expand Beyond 140 Characters to Continue Growing

If Twitter wants to continue its expansion into the mainstream, it needs to lose the 140-character limitation an! d just m arket itself as the worlds leading real-time messaging service.

I simply couldnt disagree more. Twitter does not have to expand beyond 140 characters. Why take away its heart and soul? Alternatively, here are 8 features Twitter.com should have that could actually help the microblogging service grow.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

12 startup founders discuss working on Christmas Day

Image
Well, it would seem a trifle rude to not begin proceedings with a warm Merry Christmas. But I must askwhat the hell are you doing reading this when you should be playing your new Nintendo 3DS, or guzzling that tenth mince pie of the day? But then, you will probably ask what the hell am I doing here writing this piece on the holiest of holy-days. My excuse? I love what I do, so its not like Im really working per seplus, I actually prepped much of it yesterday. And your excuse is likely along the lines of I love all things tech, why would I switch off just because my calendar says December 25? Fair point. Confucius once said: Choose a job you love, and you will never have to work a day in your life. Nice sentiments for sure, but theres still the issue of a healthy work/life balance to contend with even for startup founders. So I asked a handful of founders and CEOs whether they would be working on Christmas Day this year, or whether theyd treat themselves to a day off. I mean, it is a...
Keep reading

Flipboard needs to branch its content out from US/UK, heres why

Image
Earlier this month, an eagerly anticipated iPhone app was finally launched as Flipboard took its highly acclaimed iPad app to the phone. The app has been out for a few weeks and, with the deafening chorus of cheers fading, Ive found myself shunning its beautiful and innovative design for the simple fact that its content isnt relevant enough for me. Compared to Zite , which may not be as aesthetically pleasing, Flipboard comes up wanting on content. Zite is, among others , an app which aggregates content from my social web Twitter, Google Reader and others giving it to me in a magazine style layout. Though it lacks the page flipping ingenuity of Flipboard, the reading is more varied, which is ultimately what Im looking for from a social magazine. There is credit to be given to Flipboard however, as it is addressing the issue by building an editorial team, as its founder told Robert Scoble recently . The company has also started curating content publicly too, with @flipboardtech cura...
Keep reading

Digitimes: Apples iPhone 5 to include smaller screen and metal chassis

Contray to previous reports that suggested Apples next-generation iPhone would include a 4.2-inch touch screen panel, Asian technology publication Digitimes reports that the device will feature a smaller 4-inch panel, adapting the rear of the device to ship with a metal chassis instead of reinforced glass. Digitimes points out that the many of the rumoured specifications expected to be featured in the iPhone 5 are the markets expectations, with sources indicating that the device will possibly adopt a significantly smaller screen than first imagined: The sources pointed out that the upcoming iPhone will not have many differences compared to iPhone 4 in terms of components and the panel will still be less than 4-inch. The iPhone 5 will adopt a 3.5- to 3.7-inch panel with a design to allow the bezel of the panel to become thinner and make the screen look larger. The inclusion of a metal back will divide opinion, given suggestions that Apple had intentionally utilised glass designs to boo...
Keep reading